I picked up newspaper last week and read of an Idaho State legislator who was decrying “Obamacare” as a socialist program and that socialism should not be where the country is headed. While that’s guaranteed to get applause at a political meeting, the comments are sadly indicative of the ignorance — intentional or not — surrounding the health care issues in our country.
How good is health care in the US? Two commonly used benchmarks are Infant Mortality and Longevity. According to the CIA World Factbook, the US ranks 48th in Infant Mortality, behind countries like Hungary and Cuba. For Longevity, the US, at 78.37 years, now ranks only 50th behind countries like Finland and Canada.
Despite these dismal statistics, the US spends far more than any other country on health care. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, the most recent statistics show the US spends $7,538 per capita, which is 51% more than the next largest spender Norway, and nearly double the average of the top spending 15 countries! The statistics are pretty clear that the US is paying an incredible amount of money and getting a very poor return.
If it weren’t so sad, I would find it amusing when politicians (and others) berate “socialistic” systems when they fail to realize that we have two excellent examples of such systems here in our country. True “socialized” care means that the government owns the facilities and the doctors work for the government. This is the exact system the VA uses to care for our veterans and despite being overwhelmed and under-funded, it does an excellent job. The most common system used by other countries is not socialized but is a “single-payer” system where the facilities and doctors are private but the government pays all the bills. This is the sort of system Canada uses and, ironically, our very own Medicare system. Interestingly, both VA and Medicare operate at a fraction of the overhead costs that private insurance companies incur.
Whether the current Health Care Reform (PPACA) or some other proposal is best for our country is open for discussion. What is not debatable, however is that we should demand that our elected officials approach health care with intelligent, informed debate rather than ignorant knee-jerk political rhetoric.